Innerarity Island Homes for Sale

Welcome to Innerarity Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Pensacola, Florida. This charming subdivision offers a unique blend of coastal living and serene landscapes, making it the perfect retreat for those seeking a tranquil lifestyle. Surrounded by the sparkling waters of Perdido Bay and just a stone's throw from the Gulf of Mexico, Innerarity Island is a paradise for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts alike.

The community is known for its stunning waterfront properties, many of which boast private docks and breathtaking views. Imagine waking up to the gentle sound of waves lapping at your doorstep and enjoying your morning coffee while watching the sunrise over the bay. With a variety of homes for sale, you can find the perfect residence that fits your style and budget—whether it’s a cozy beach cottage or a luxurious waterfront estate.

Residents of Innerarity Island enjoy a laid-back lifestyle with easy access to local amenities, including boutique shops, delightful dining options, and recreational activities. Spend your weekends fishing, kayaking, or simply soaking up the sun on the nearby beaches. The community also offers a strong sense of belonging, with friendly neighbors and a welcoming atmosphere.

If you’re ready to embrace the coastal lifestyle and explore the homes for sale in Innerarity Island, now is the perfect time to make your move. Discover the charm of this unique subdivision and start your journey toward your dream home in beautiful Pensacola, Florida!

Newest Innerarity Island Homes for Sale

$850,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 398856 MLS

Experience elevated coastal living with this stunning new construction home on Innerarity Island. Tucked away on a quiet street backing up to a conservation area, this thoughtfully designed 4-bedroom plus an office, 3.5-bath home offers privacy, quality construction, and exceptional attention to detail. Step inside to soaring ceilings and an open floor plan. The main living area features impressive 12-foot ceilings with 12'8" coffered ceiling detail, while 10-foot ceilings throughout the remainder of the home create a spacious and airy feel. Oversized 9-foot windows flood the living spaces with natural light and frame the peaceful natural surroundings. The kitchen opens seamlessly to the living and dining areas and comes complete with all kitchen appliances included. Luxury vinyl plank flooring runs throughout the home, offering both beauty and durability with no carpet to maintain. The spacious primary suite features a luxurious tiled walk-in shower and spa-like bath. Three additional bedrooms and 2.5 guest baths provide plenty of room for family and guests. Designed to embrace indoor and outdoor living, the home features a gas fireplace in both the living room and the covered back patio, creating inviting spaces to gather year-round. Double French door open onto the expansive covered patio overlooking the private backyard and conservation area. Built with quality and efficiency in mind, the home features durable brick and Hardie siding construction along with upgraded 2x6 exterior walls. The oversized two-car garage offers abundant storage space and includes garage doors on both the front and rear of the home. Rarely does new construction on Innerarity Island combine this level of craftsmanship, privacy, and thoughtful design. Enjoy island living just minutes from beaches, marinas, restaurants, and shopping while surrounded by the natural beauty of Innerarity Island. Expected completion fall 2026. Buyer to verify all information during due diligence.

5581 Seascape St, Pensacola

$850,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 685239 MLS

Experience elevated coastal living with this stunning new construction home on desirable Innerarity Island. Tucked away on a quiet street backing up to a conservation area, this thoughtfully designed 4-bedroom plus an office, 3.5-bath home offers privacy, quality construction, and exceptional attention to detail. Step inside to soaring ceilings and an open floor plan. The main living area features impressive 12-foot ceilings with 12'8" coffered ceiling detail, while 10-foot ceilings throughout the remainder of the home create a spacious and airy feel. Oversized 9-foot windows flood the living spaces with natural light and frame the peaceful natural surroundings. The kitchen opens seamlessly to the living and dining areas and comes complete with all kitchen appliances included. Luxury vinyl plank flooring runs throughout the home, offering both beauty and durability with no carpet to maintain. The spacious primary suite features a luxurious tiled walk-in shower and spa-like bath. Three additional bedrooms and 2.5 guest baths provide plenty of room for family and guests. Designed to embrace indoor and outdoor living, the home features a gas fireplace in both the living room and the covered back patio, creating inviting spaces to gather year-round. Double French door open onto the expansive covered patio overlooking the private backyard and conservation area. Built with quality and efficiency in mind, the home features durable brick and Hardie siding construction along with upgraded 2x6 exterior walls. The oversized two-car garage offers abundant storage space and includes garage doors on both the front and rear of the home. Rarely does new construction on Innerarity Island combine this level of craftsmanship, privacy, and thoughtful design. Enjoy island living just minutes from beaches, marinas, restaurants, and shopping while surrounded by the natural beauty that makes Innerarity Island one of Perdido Key's most desirable communities. Expected completion fall 2026.

5581 Seascape Dr, Pensacola

$699,000

3 Beds ⋅ 684665 MLS

VA Assumable Loan at 3.375% to qualified buyers. Move-in ready! Stunning Custom Brick Home on Innerarity Island | 3 Bed / 2.5 Bath. Welcome to one of Innerarity Island's most thoughtfully crafted homes — a traditional, stately custom brick residence nestled in this quiet, peaceful gated community just minutes from Florida and Alabama's famous white sandy beaches, shopping, and dining. Set on a generous .70-acre lot spanning two parcels. Impact glass and doors, spray foam insulation, and timeless brick construction throughout. Inside, Chicago brick flooring flows through the entire home beneath 9' ceilings, crown molding, tray ceilings, plantation shutters, bay windows, and recessed lighting that together create a warm, refined atmosphere from the moment you step through the door. The heart of the home is the oversized great room, anchored by a brick raised-hearth gas fireplace and a pass-through wet bar — ideal for entertaining. It opens seamlessly into the chef's kitchen, featuring granite countertops, custom soft-close cabinetry, a 5-Star gas cooktop with griddle, exhaust hood, two Maytag wall ovens, a Bosch dishwasher, a large walk-in pantry, breakfast bar, and a separate dining area. French doors lead to a screened covered patio, a roughed-in outdoor kitchen, and a firepit with seating. The primary suite is a true sanctuary, offering a bay window, a walk-in closet in the bedroom and the bath, double granite vanities, a clawfoot tub, a walk-in tiled shower with wall jets and waterfall head (fed by a tankless water heater), and a private water closet. Every additional bedroom features plantation shutters and bay windows for that same bright, classic feel. Practical luxury continues with an oversized 3-car garage (nearly 1,000 sq ft), a large utility/laundry room with a deep sink, and a 12x16 floored attic for additional storage. Enjoy the park, picnic area, fishing, pickleball court and breaktaking sunset views over Perdido Bay.

16340 Innerarity Pt Rd, Pensacola

$1,127,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 397989 MLS

Completely Renovated Waterfront Retreat on Innerarity IslandThis is more than a home—it’s an opportunity to enjoy effortless waterfront living in a beautifully updated residence where every day feels like a vacation Experience best of Gulf Coast living in this beautifully renovated waterfront home on sought-after Innerarity Island. Perfectly positioned to capture panoramic water views, this exceptional residence combines timeless coastal elegance with modern upgrades, offering a move-in-ready lifestyle in one of Pensacola’s loveliest gated communities.No detail has been overlooked in the home's extensive renovation. Enjoy all-new appliances, new flooring throughout, Impact-resistant windows, a 2021 HVAC system, Water heater, and a 2021 roof, providing peace of mind and energy-efficient living for years to come. The spacious Master Bath features double vanities, freestanding tub and separate shower with body jet spray system for the ultimate Spa experience in addition to two walk-in closets. The Oversized Garage features a Half Bath next to storage room that could be the perfect workshop!Inside, expansive windows flood the home with natural light while showcasing breathtaking water views from nearly every room including a waterfront Sunroom inviting you to enjoy a lazy afternoon reading a book or simply watching the Osprey’s in their nest! This floor plan features spacious living areas, soaring ceilings, and seamless indoor-outdoor flow, making it great for both entertaining and everyday relaxation. The updated kitchen opens effortlessly to the main living spaces, while the private primary suite offers a tranquil retreat with stunning waterfront vistas.Step outside to your own slice of paradise where you can enjoy morning coffee, spectacular sunsets as you enjoy the twinkling lights among the oaks as you relax in the waterfront swing enjoying the serenity of life on the water. Whether boating, fishing, kayaking, paddleboarding, or simply watching dolphins Buyer Buye

5466 N Shore Rd, Pensacola

$559,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 683866 MLS

Behind the gates of highly sought-after Innerarity Island, this beautifully updated brick home blends indoor comfort, outdoor living, and everyday functionality. This private gated community offers a relaxed coastal lifestyle and is bike, pedestrian, and golf cart friendly, with a waterfront park featuring a dock, kayak launch, picnic tables, pickleball and basketball courts, and swings. The split floor plan features 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, and a flexible bonus room ideal for formal dining, office, playroom, or additional living space. Inside, you’ll find wood-look tile throughout, 9-foot ceilings, a vaulted great room ceiling, 5-panel doors, and custom Craftsman-style trim. The updated kitchen includes quartz countertops, farmhouse sink, stainless appliances, breakfast nook, and wet bar. The spacious primary suite opens directly to the pool area and includes a spa-like bath with walk-in shower, granite countertops, soaking tub, private water closet, and custom walk-in closet. Step outside to a backyard retreat among sprawling live oaks. The fully privacy-fenced backyard and screened pool area feature a saltwater gunite pool with full-length seating bench, large tanning ledge with bubbler, expansive pool deck, and covered patio. The outdoor bar includes concrete countertops, storage, and two beverage refrigerators, with a 6-person hot tub nearby. Additional features include a laundry room with deep sink, wine cooler, and large folding counter, garage shelving, new roof in 2025, water heater replaced in 2020, and excellent parking flexibility with a 75+ ft concrete driveway, 40+ ft millings extension, and 12-ft double gate to the backyard - ideal for boat, camper, trailer, or extra vehicle parking. This Innerarity Island home combines privacy, thoughtful updates, outdoor living, and practical storage in one of the area’s most desirable gated communities.

16660 Innerarity Pt Rd, Pensacola

$1,300,000

3 Beds ⋅ 683667 MLS

This gorgeous, newly custom-built home is the epitome of coastal luxury & fortification. Its unparalleled western views over the Intercoastal Waterway, paired with exceptional design & construction standards, make this a once in a lifetime home. The property includes 3 beds, 2.5 baths across 2306 sqft indoors, 2612 sqft of storage & a 3 car garage, and 933 sqft of outdoor living area. The vaulted ceilings and vast windows of the main room bring in abundant natural light and views. The screened-in deck offers exceptional sunsets, a hardline gas outdoor kitchen, a hot tub on a reinforced deck, and custom retractable shades. All living area is on the single upper level where you enjoy the safety & views of the elevated home with the convenience of the full-size elevator! Uncompromising standards are evident throughout and begin well beyond what can be seen. Boasting a Gold Fortification Standard, the home exceptionally built and is very affordably insured. The entire structure sits above the flood zone, allowing the garage level to have a bathroom, elevator access, and all be insured! All windows and doors are impact resistant glass, always keeping the home protected. The vast list of upgrades continue with 2 Geothermal HVAC systems, full metal roof, all composite decking, tankless gas water heater, central vacuum system, all stainless & aluminum handrail systems, high end shower jet systems, all automatic shades, backlit granite throughout the custom kitchen and wet bar, 400 amp power supply with 2 EV chargers, whole house water filtration system, reverse osmosis system, large horseshoe drive, and fans, heaters, & speakers throughout the decks and garage. The foundation is wrapped by a professionally installed retaining bed, designed for protection and green thumb enthusiasts. All of this, nestled within the private, quiet, elegant Innerarity Island neighborhood with a community park and beach boardwalk walking distance away. Don’t miss this stunning opportunity!

5402 North Shore Rd, Pensacola

$557,500

4 Beds ⋅ 670456 MLS

THIS IS MORE THAN A HOME — IT’S A PRIVATE COASTAL RETREAT DESIGNED FOR RELAXATION, ENTERTAINING, AND LAID-BACK ISLAND-STYLE LIVING! The sparkling inground pool, expansive screened enclosure with hot tub, and private backyard oasis with no rear neighbors create the perfect setting for hosting friends, relaxing poolside, or unwinding after a day at the beach. Warm, inviting, and thoughtfully designed, this home creates a truly special atmosphere from the moment you walk through the door. The spacious layout, seamless indoor-outdoor living, and beautifully designed gathering spaces create the perfect setting for making memories with family and friends for years to come. This meticulously maintained home offers the ideal blend of privacy, comfort, and livability. Major updates including a newer roof, HVAC system, and whole-home generator provide peace of mind for years to come. Designed with entertaining in mind, the fabulous floor plan features large open living spaces with durable luxury vinyl flooring, elegant tile, and a cozy fireplace that anchors the main living area. Large sliding glass doors provide beautiful backyard views and seamless access to the expansive screened lanai, creating effortless indoor-outdoor flow for gatherings year-round. The kitchen features abundant wood cabinetry, updated stainless steel appliances, and a convenient double wall oven perfect for hosting family and friends. The spacious primary suite serves as a private retreat with a sitting area or home office, private outdoor access, and a spa-inspired bathroom featuring a beautifully tiled walk-in shower and double vanity. Nestled within the quiet, gated community of Innerarity Island and just minutes from the beaches of Perdido Key and NAS Pensacola, this exceptional home is perfectly suited for full-time living or a private second-home retreat. Schedule your private showing today!

16531 Innerarity Pt Rd, Pensacola

Start Your Search

© Baldwin County Association of Realtors, Inc. Information deemed to be reliable but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocitysm Program. Listing broker has attempted to offer accurate data, but buyers are advised to confirm all items. Information last updated on .